Prices and features as of October 2026, checked on each app’s official site and US App Store listing on October 10, 2026. Sources are listed at the end. Prices change; check the listing before you buy.
We make Dishpin, one of the apps on this list, so you should read this knowing we have a horse in the race. We’ve tried to make it the comparison we’d want to read: specific, sourced, and clear about where the others are better than us. In several places they are.
The short version
- Best all-rounder, especially across devices: Paprika.
- Best for Apple fans who care about privacy: Mela.
- Best if you use Android or Windows too: Recipe Keeper (or Paprika).
- Best for Apple gadget lovers: Crouton.
- Best if you just want something free, right now: Apple Notes.
- Best for recipes from TikTok and Instagram videos: Dishpin.
| App | Runs on | Price (US) | Import from social video | Import from photos | Meal plan |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Paprika 3 | iPhone, iPad, Mac, Windows, Android | $4.99 iOS, $29.99 Mac, one-time per platform | No (in Paprika 4 beta) | No (in Paprika 4 beta) | Yes |
| Mela | iPhone, iPad, Mac | Free, $6.99 iOS / $14.99 Mac unlock | From the video’s description | Yes, text recognition | Via Calendar |
| Recipe Keeper | iPhone, iPad, Mac, Windows, Android | Free, Pro $19.99 iOS / $29.99 Mac | Instagram and TikTok | Yes, OCR | Yes |
| Crouton | iPhone, iPad, Mac, Watch, Vision Pro | Free, Plus $24.99, Discover $14.99/yr | Not listed | Yes, AI and OCR | Yes |
| Apple Notes | Every Apple device, iCloud.com | Free | No | Scans as images | No |
| Dishpin | iPhone | Free (5 imports a month), Plus subscription | Reads the video itself | Yes, AI | Yes Plus after week one |
Paprika
Paprika has been the default answer to “which recipe app?” for years, and it earns it. It runs on iPhone, iPad, Mac, Windows and Android, and syncs recipes, grocery lists and meal plans between them for free with a Paprika account.
What it does best: the whole kitchen system. Its browser imports recipes from websites, the meal planner does days, weeks and months, the grocery list sorts by aisle and merges duplicates, and there’s a pantry that tracks quantities and expiry dates. Cook mode keeps the screen on and highlights your current step, and it detects timers in the directions automatically. You pay once per platform: $4.99 on iPhone, $29.99 on Mac.
Where it falls short: paying per platform adds up if you want it everywhere. Paprika 3 has no photo or social-video import, and nutrition is a field you fill in yourself.
What’s changing: Paprika 4 entered open beta on September 28, 2026, adding scanning, social media import, nutritional analysis and family sharing. Hindsight Labs says premium features will need a subscription after the beta; prices haven’t been announced.
Choose Paprika if you want one mature system across every device you own, and you plan your week and your shopping in detail. It beats Dishpin here clearly: Dishpin is iPhone-only and has no pantry.
Mela
Mela is the beautiful one. It’s free to download with a one-time Mela+ unlock ($6.99 on iPhone and iPad, $14.99 on Mac), syncs through your own iCloud, and its developer says it collects no data at all.
What it does best: fitting into Apple’s own apps. Meal plans live in Calendar and grocery lists in Reminders, so your partner can see the shopping list without installing anything. It imports from websites with an in-app browser that spots recipes as you browse, reads printed recipes with text recognition, and its full-screen cook mode supports several recipes at once.
Where it falls short: Mela reads recipes from a video’s description, not the video itself, so recipes that are only spoken don’t come through. It’s Apple-only, and updates have slowed: the last iPhone update listed on the App Store was in June 2025.
Choose Mela if you live in Apple’s world, value privacy and design, and mostly cook from websites and books.
Recipe Keeper
Recipe Keeper is the practical, everywhere option. It runs on iPhone, iPad, Mac, Windows and Android, and syncs recipes, shopping lists and meal plans across all of them.
What it does best: breadth. It scans recipes from the camera, photos and PDFs with OCR, imports from hundreds of recipe sites, and has added Instagram and TikTok import. Weekly and monthly meal plans, a shopping list sorted by aisle, and even an Alexa skill.
Where it falls short: like Paprika, Pro is bought per platform ($19.99 on iPhone, $29.99 on Mac). The free version is limited; check the listing for the current cap before you commit your collection to it. The design feels older than the Apple-only apps.
Choose Recipe Keeper if your household mixes iPhone and Android, or you want a recipe box on a Windows laptop in the kitchen.
Crouton
Crouton is the most actively developed Apple-only app here, with an update as recently as September 2026. It runs on iPhone, iPad, Mac, Apple Watch and even Vision Pro.
What it does best: cooking with Apple gadgets. Step-by-step cook mode now works hands-free with gestures, timers show as Live Activities on your Watch, and it connects to Bluetooth kitchen scales and the Combustion thermometer. It imports from web addresses, cookbook scans (AI and OCR), photos, text and PDFs, and can generate a meal plan from your saved recipes.
Where it falls short: pricing has layers. Crouton is free with in-app purchases, including a one-time Crouton Plus ($24.99) and a Discover subscription ($1.99 a month or $14.99 a year), and the listing doesn’t spell out which features sit in which tier. Social video import isn’t mentioned on its official pages.
Choose Crouton if you have an Apple Watch on your wrist while you cook, or love kitchen hardware.
Apple Notes
Don’t laugh. Notes is free, already on your phone, syncs through iCloud, and its document scanner captures a cookbook page in seconds. Live Text lets you copy text out of any photo.
Where it falls short: a note is not a recipe. No ingredient checklist, no scaling, no timers, no meal plan, no shopping list that knows what an ingredient is. Scans stay as pictures unless you copy the text out yourself.
Choose Notes if you save a few recipes a month and mostly want them not to disappear.
Dishpin
Dishpin is new, and it’s ours. As of October 2026 it’s in testing ahead of its App Store launch, so it’s the least proven app on this list.
What it does best: recipes from short videos. Share a TikTok or Instagram post to Dishpin and it turns the video into a recipe. Even recipes that exist only as a creator talking over a pan come through with amounts, steps and timers, and the creator stays credited with a link to the post. It also imports recipe websites, cookbook photos and pasted text, and recognises a post you’ve already saved. Once you cook, Dishpin keeps a journal of your meals with photos, notes and stickers.
Where it falls short:
- iPhone only. No iPad, Mac, Android or web version.
- No pantry, and no export yet.
- No YouTube. It reads TikTok and Instagram videos, not YouTube Shorts.
- Free has a cap: 5 imports every 30 days (cooking a saved recipe earns more, up to three a week). Unlimited imports need Plus Plus.
- Several features others include in a one-time price are part of the Plus subscription: guided cooking mode Plus, nutrition Plus, US/metric conversion Plus, and meal planning after your first week Plus.
Choose Dishpin if most of your recipes start as TikToks and Reels, and you want them to become something you can actually cook from. See how saving from TikTok works, or our head-to-head Paprika vs Dishpin.
How to choose
Ask yourself two questions:
- Where do your recipes come from? Mostly websites and books: Paprika, Mela or Crouton. Mostly short videos: Dishpin, with Recipe Keeper and Mela worth a look. A bit of everything, rarely: Notes.
- Where do you cook from? Any non-Apple device in the house rules out Mela, Crouton and Dishpin. A Watch on your wrist points to Crouton. An iPad propped on the counter rules out Dishpin today.
And whichever you choose, check how you’d get your recipes out again before you put 500 in.
Sources
Checked October 10, 2026. Prices are US App Store prices in USD.
- Paprika: paprikaapp.com, iPhone listing, Mac listing, Paprika 4 beta news, Mac help: timers and fields
- Mela: mela.recipes, iPhone listing, Mac listing
- Recipe Keeper: recipekeeperonline.com, iPhone listing, Mac listing
- Crouton: crouton.app, iPhone listing
- Apple Notes: Scan documents in Notes, Live Text
- Dishpin: the app’s own code and our import tests, October 2026.




